Auto Insurance Deductible Choice Calculator
Net expected savings + break-even years when raising your auto insurance deductible
Try the calculator
Reviewed against primary sources.
Assumptions
$
$
$
$
Net expected annual savings
$175.00
Premium savings minus the expected extra out-of-pocket. Positive β raising the deductible is rational on average.
Annual premium savings$200.00
Break-even years on a single claim2.5
Expected-value math assumes you can comfortably afford the higher deductible if a claim happens. If a $1000 unexpected expense would create financial hardship, the lower-deductible option may be the right call regardless of expected savings.
What is an auto insurance deductible choice?
How to use this calculator
- Current deductible (default: 500)
- Current annual premium (default: 1500)
- Alternate (higher) deductible (default: 1000)
- Alternate annual premium (lower) (default: 1300)
- Claims expected per year (default: 0.05)
- Read the result. Use the worked examples below to sanity-check against a known scenario.
How we built this calculator
Methodology
Last updated
2026-05-09
Calculation runs
Client-side only
Sources & references
Every numeric assumption traces to a primary source.